Get Your FREE Ultimate Weekend Packing Cheat Sheet!

Dining in the Deep End at Cafe Alcazar St Augustine FL PullOverAndLetMeOut
Picture of Anna Marie

Anna Marie

Dining in the Deep End at Café Alcazar in St. Augustine, Florida

Travel with PullOverAndLetMeOut to the historic Café Alcazar in St. Augustine's Lightner Museum for a delicious luncheon meal. The food is so tasty that you'll want to dive right in!
A woman sipping coffee outside
Hi, I’m Anna Marie. I’m a wife, mother, Irish dancer, and pug mom living in North Carolina. I also love to travel. Come along for the ride! If you see something you like, don’t be afraid to say, ‘Pull over and let me out.’

Café Alcazar offers a rather unique dining experience. This lovely, somewhat off-the-beaten-path restaurant is housed in what was formerly the world’s largest indoor pool, behind the Lightner Art Museum. Once a part of the fabled Hotel Alcazar, this swimming pool turned restaurant serves up tasty food in a special dining environment and is a must-visit while touring the historic Old Town of St. Augustine.

people waiting for a table at a restaurant in what was the world's largest indoor swimming pool
The Cafe Alcazar located in what was once the world's largest indoor swimming pool.

The Largest Indoor Swimming Pool

In his attempt to create a “Riviera” on the eastern seaboard of the United States, Henry Flagler built the Hotel Alcazar as part of a complex of three Moorish-Spanish buildings in 1887-1889. Flagler, a railroad magnate and an associate in the creation of Standard Oil with John D. Rockefeller, built the grand hotel for more than a million dollars as a sister hotel to his first hotel project, The Ponce de Leon, just up the street. Back in the late 1800s and early 1900s, the Hotel Alcazar was the place to stay.

Architecturally, the hotel was a work of art. Its four stories, luxurious rooms, and grand open spaces were breathtaking and the pinnacle of elegance. The hotel’s recreation areas were equally impressive.

Turkish and Russian spas, Swedish massage services, and other similar activities were located in the building’s south section. It was thought that the natural artesian water used here had medicinal properties. It came from a well on the property that was free-flowing. Adjoining the baths was and are the magnificent Casino, and what at the time was known as the world’s largest indoor swimming pool.

historic pictures on a wall
The swimming pool was once considered the largest indoor pool in the world.

Dining at Café Alcazar

Today, the large swimming pool serves as the Cafe Alcazar, where diners may have a mid-day meal in an interesting and historic environment that harkens back to the bygone Guilded Age while paying homage to its glorious history.

Located a short walk from the campus of Flagler College and historic Old Town St. Augustine, this is a great spot that’s in the heart of the tourist area yet not touristy. We found a metered parking space a block away and walked right inside the Granada Street entrance.

We were seated promptly at a table in the “deep end” and our waiter, Sean, was extremely helpful in guiding us through the menu. Jason and I opted for a cup of Chef Kevin’s special cream of mushroom soup paired with half a sandwich while my son selected the roast beef sandwich. Everything was exquisite. I had a turkey cranberry sandwich that came with a cranberry aioli that is out-of-this-world! I kept talking about it all afternoon!

Besides that, the atmosphere was fantastic. I sat in awe, my gaze wandering around the architecture and art that surrounded us.

cream of mushroom soup and a half sandwich
The food was AMAZING!
Enter through the museum or via the Granada Street entrance.
PullOver Pro Tip picture

The restaurant is open 7 days a week from 11:00 a.m. to 3:00 p.m. It's also available for private parties, rehearsal dinners, and special occasions. While reservations aren't required, they are strongly encouraged, especially from October through March!

The Lightner Museum

The glory days of the Hotel Alcazar ended during the dark days of the Depression in 1930. The building sat empty until Otto C. Lightner purchased it in 1947. After much rehabilitation and work, the building was restored to its current appearance and began welcoming exhibits from the Chicago Museum of Art. 

The Lightner Museum has its own intriguing history. It now houses tens of thousands of pieces, mostly from the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, including fine and decorative art, folk art, natural history specimens, and material culture.

Admission to the museum is reasonably priced and well worth it to take a look at the impressive Gilded Age collection belonging to Otto Lightner as well as the current exhibits. My one regret is that I didn’t get to tour the museum. I’ll save that one for another time when the guys aren’t with me. 

3 classic postcards
A postcard as a souvenir of our meal.
a sign that says Lightner Museum
"Lightner Museum offers an immersive experience of art, architecture, history, and design"

Would I dine here again?

I enjoy discovering unusual locations that are off the main route. While the historic old Hotel Alcazar is a well-known sight in Old Town St. Augustine, the unconventional café in the swimming pool is a bit off the main path.

I learned about this unusual cafe from my hairdresser who is originally from St. Augustine. I’m delighted I took her recommendation! The food was scrumptious. The setting was incredible. The service was outstanding. And best of all, it was out of the ordinary. When our meal was done, our bill came with a complimentary classic postcard as a keepsake of our most enjoyable and memorable meal of the trip.

Yes! I’d absolutely dine here again!

Café Alcazar
25 Granada Street, St. Augustine, FL, 32084

A statue at the top of a staircase
The Cafe Alcazar creates a unique dining experience.

Hey, Pinners! Pin this for later!

► Plan Your Trip to St. Augustine Now!


It makes it simple to plan your trip.   We’ve pre-filled the destination from the article and if there are multiple places mentioned in the article, we’ve put the one that is best used as your base to see all of the places mentioned.

Just select I’M STAYING and enter the travel dates and hit SEARCH.  It automatically uses the first place in the article.  

For a multi-day trip, if you stay near that location, you should be able to use it as your base.

Super simple.  Just click on the pencil and enter the name of any place mentioned in the story.  Or you can enter any address or even the name of a company if you are mixing business and pleasure.

Just click I’M DRIVING and you can see how long it will take, get driving directions and even rent a car if you need one.

Yes, we guarantee the best published rates on hotels.  Click on the link for BEST RATE 110% GUARANTEE for details.

Share your experiences  

Hey pinners, save this for pinning after your trip

After you get back from your trip, please use these images to post to social media or post your own photos.  Please tag us on your post #pulloverandletmeout
You can also use the social sharing links on the SmartTrip tool.

More travel stories you'll love reading!

Cover photo two pints of Guinness

What You Need to Know Before You Order That Pint of Guinness

Few beverages are as closely linked to a location as Guinness is to Ireland. Rich in heritage, the creamy dark stout is a daily staple at pubs and bars across Ireland and the world. Travel along with Pull Over and Let Me Out to the Emerald Isle and learn what you need to know before you order that pint of Guinness.

Read More »

Let’s Get Social!
Click below and join the conversation on social media

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top

FREE Access to Exclusive Travel Tips and Deals

Get the latest travel news, tips & information from!

Save on Membership with


don't leave empty-handed

Get your FREE Ultimate Weekend Packing Cheat Sheet

Happy Travels