Get Your FREE Ultimate Weekend Packing Cheat Sheet!

Why The Black Fedora Charleston SC PullOverandLetMeOut (2)
Picture of Anna Marie

Anna Marie

Why the Black Fedora Theater is a Comedy “Must” in Charleston, South Carolina

Travel with PullOverandLetMeOut to historic Charleston, South Carolina and discover why The Black Fedora Theater is a laugh-a-minute itinerary item you won't want to miss.
A woman sipping coffee outside
Hi, I’m Anna Marie. I’m a wife, mother, Irish dancer, and pug mom living in North Carolina. I also love to travel. Come along for the ride! If you see something you like, don’t be afraid to say, ‘Pull over and let me out.’

“Something Funny’s Going On in Downtown Charleston!” And that’s precisely why I recommend including the Black Fedora Comedy Mystery Theater on your Charleston itinerary. This happy “Mom & Pop” theater just past the House of Jerky on Church Street in the heart of the historic district, welcomes locals and guests alike to enjoy live interactive plays served up with just the right amount of silliness and spontaneity to create a magical memorable night on the town.

picture of a small empty theater
Live interactive plays in an intimate setting.

Charleston Entertainment

Always on the lookout for unique and different things to do while traveling, I happened upon the Black Fedora Theater in 2016 while planning a Christmastime visit to Charleston. I was intrigued by the concept and excited to enjoy a play while experiencing the Charleston theater scene.

That being said, this is no ordinary theater experience. The cozy venue “where all the room’s a stage,” is the ideal setting for watching a comedic play where audience members, if they choose to, can become part of the cast of these original comedies/mysteries.

My husband, son, and I were supremely entertained by Inspector NoClue’s Mystery so when my group of girlfriends and I were planning a getaway to the Charleston area, I had one agenda item to suggest – The Black Fedora Theater!

five women in front of the entrance to the Black Fedora Theater in Charleston, SC
Our girls' getaway at The Black Fedora Theater

What to Expect at The Black Fedora Theater

The theater is comfy and intimate, which adds to the fun. The relaxed atmosphere and casual setting, adorned with an array of “detective” portraits, allow the entertainment to begin the moment you walk in.

Once seated, guests are encouraged to explore the walls and play “Name that Detective.” Work alone or in groups with your friends to identify as many of the infamous sleuths on the walls as possible.

Although this is not a dinner theater, they do serve drinks, snacks, and homemade desserts. Order before the show starts and enjoy. 

Audience members are invited to volunteer for roles in the play prior to the performance. There are small and larger parts, all of which are well-scripted, making it simple to follow along and become a “star.” Even if only for a moment.

If you’d rather remain anonymous, simply sit back and immerse yourself in solving the mystery. It’s completely up to you.

Five women in a theater
Our group used team-work to identify the sleuths on the wall.
PullOver Pro Tip picture

Owners Darryl & Sherry Wade relocated from Atlanta where they spent two decades producing live entertainment for corporate audiences. Now they've been blessed by more than a decade in the Lowcountry, working with a group of talented, friendly, funny people, with a mission to serve their guests in a spirit of humor, playfulness and joy.

The Play is the Thing!

As their website says, “All our shows are clean comic whodunits, and they all feature YOU — or at least some brave soul sitting near you who volunteers for a role!”

The Black Fedora features two-hour original shows written in-house that are comedic gold. Audiences are able to choose from shows such as Inspector NoClue’s Murder Mystery Show, Murder at the Redneck Reunion, and Help! I Think My Characters Are Trying To Kill Me!

We had the pleasure of watching and performing in Mack Black: Ghost Detective – He’s Dead… He Just Doesn’t Know It… Yet! The 1930s murder mystery stars Mack Black, a private investigator, as well as a cast of ghostly characters and an underworld figure known as the “Lizard.”

It is a crowd-pleaser and a laugh-a-minute ride from start to finish.

actors in a theater
Audience members become the stars!

Planning Your Visit to The Black Fedora Comedy Mystery Theater

At 164 Church Street, The Black Fedora is just steps away from Charleston’s famous City Market. There is plenty of street parking as well as several parking garages nearby. Likewise, there are numerous restaurants within walking distance if you want to combine dinner and theater. And because the theater is in the historic district, it’s a pleasant stroll away from a multitude of hotels, inns, and accommodations, including one of my favorite Charleston B&Bs, the John Rutledge House Inn. (Read More)

The Black Fedora is cozy and casual, with the main goal of making people laugh and allowing the audience to become stars for the evening. Each show lasts about two hours and is pure entertainment. There is no foul language or anything crude, but the shows are not intended for children under six. My son was 12 at the time of my first visit, and it was ideal family entertainment.

Best of all, tickets to the show are reasonably priced. Visit the theater’s website to find out about showtimes and availability. The theater doors open thirty minutes before showtime, and it is strongly advised that you purchase tickets in advance at the theater or online because it is a small theater, and shows sell out quickly.

a woman reading a script
"You're one of us, now!" Eileen's big line.
A man reading a script
Steve made the perfect "Shaggy."
A cast picture at a theater
The post-production cast photo

Take Away

The Black Fedora Comedy Mystery Theater provides visitors with a one-of-a-kind memorable theater experience filled with mystery and laughter. Whether you take on a role in the play or just watch, this charming theater is a comedic “must” when visiting historic Charleston, South Carolina. That is what I call a Pull Over and Let Me Out winner!

The Black Fedora Comedy Mystery Theater
162 Church Street
Charleston, SC

Hey, Pinners! Pin This for Later!

► Plan Your Trip to Charleston, Now!


It makes it simple to plan your trip.   We’ve pre-filled the destination from the article and if there are multiple places mentioned in the article, we’ve put the one that is best used as your base to see all of the places mentioned.

Just select I’M STAYING and enter the travel dates and hit SEARCH.  It automatically uses the first place in the article.  

For a multi-day trip, if you stay near that location, you should be able to use it as your base.

Super simple.  Just click on the pencil and enter the name of any place mentioned in the story.  Or you can enter any address or even the name of a company if you are mixing business and pleasure.

Just click I’M DRIVING and you can see how long it will take, get driving directions and even rent a car if you need one.

Yes, we guarantee the best published rates on hotels.  Click on the link for BEST RATE 110% GUARANTEE for details.

Share your experiences  

Hey pinners, save this for pinning after your trip

After you get back from your trip, please use these images to post to social media or post your own photos.  Please tag us on your post #pulloverandletmeout
You can also use the social sharing links on the SmartTrip tool.
Paws for Purple Hearts logo

More Great Travel Stories You'll Love!

Cover photo two pints of Guinness

What You Need to Know Before You Order That Pint of Guinness

Few beverages are as closely linked to a location as Guinness is to Ireland. Rich in heritage, the creamy dark stout is a daily staple at pubs and bars across Ireland and the world. Travel along with Pull Over and Let Me Out to the Emerald Isle and learn what you need to know before you order that pint of Guinness.

Read More »

Let’s Get Social!
Click below and join the conversation on social media

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top

FREE Access to Exclusive Travel Tips and Deals

Get the latest travel news, tips & information from!

Save on Membership with


don't leave empty-handed

Get your FREE Ultimate Weekend Packing Cheat Sheet

Happy Travels